Removing the console top is proving difficult.
There are two bolts that I cannot reach unless I remove both seats.
I removed the oval shaped ring around the gear shift to see if I could find anything and it does indeed look like there is crusted, dried stuff on the inside.
I cleaned it as best as I could and now it's recognizing it's in park.
Let's see how long that lasts
EDIT:
Would it be harmful to spray any kind of adhesive remover (ie: goof-off, WD40 etc) into the gear shifter or would that make the problem worse?